High Court dismisses £1.3 billion National Lottery procurement challenge
The High Court throws out Lottery Licence challenge
The High Court has comprehensively dismissed a major procurement challenge arising from the competition for the fourth UK National Lottery Licence, rejecting claims for damages of up to £1.3 billion brought against the Gambling Commission.
The judgment represents one of the most significant procurement challenge decisions in recent years and reinforces the high threshold claimants must meet when seeking to overturn complex, high value public procurement competitions.
Background and facts
The challenge was brought by Northern & Shell plc and The New Lottery Company Limited, following the award of the fourth National Lottery Licence to Allwyn in 2022.
The claimants described the process as “the most financially significant procurement process in UK history”. Their case related both to:
-
the conduct of the procurement competition itself; and
-
subsequent modifications made to the licence following award
Damages of up to £1.3 billion were claimed, reflecting the scale and commercial importance of the opportunity. The trial lasted for more than two months, culminating in a detailed 280 page judgment.
The High Court judgment
The High Court rejected the claims in their entirety, finding decisively in favour of the Gambling Commission.
This decision marks the third consecutive successful outcome for the Gambling Commission in litigation arising from the National Lottery competition, following earlier challenges brought by Camelot and IGT.
The Court endorsed the robustness of the Commission’s procurement process and rejected allegations that the competition or subsequent licence modifications were unlawful.
Get in touch
Key takeaways for procurement challenges
The judgment provides several important lessons for both contracting authorities and bidders:
- Courts give significant deference in complex procurements
In highly technical, evaluative and policy laden procurements, the Court will be slow to interfere absent clear errors of law or manifest unfairness. - High evidential threshold for damages
Very substantial damages claims require equally compelling evidence of breach and causation. The scale of loss alone does not lower the legal threshold. - Litigation risk does not automatically equate to vulnerability
Even large scale procurements attracting repeated challenges can withstand scrutiny where governance, documentation and evaluation processes are robust. - Modifications post award can be defended
Lawful modifications to contracts or licences, where properly justified and documented, are not inherently vulnerable to challenge.
Practical points for authorities and bidders
- Contracting authorities should continue to invest in transparent evaluation processes, clear audit trails and defensible decision making, particularly on major projects
- Bidders should approach procurement challenges with a realistic view of the high bar set by the courts, particularly when seeking damages rather than procedural remedies
- Early advice and risk assessment remain critical before commencing high value procurement litigation
Procurement Act 2023 – impact for local authorities
Although the National Lottery challenge pre dates the Procurement Act 2023, the judgment provides strong reassurance for local authorities delivering complex, high value and politically sensitive procurements.
Under the new regime, suppliers retain access to automatic suspension, damages and (in limited cases) contract set aside, but courts are expected to maintain a high bar for intervention, particularly where authorities can evidence lawful decision making, proportionality and clear audit trails. The Act’s codified test for interim relief places explicit weight on the public interest in avoiding service disruption and project delay, which is likely to favour authorities procuring essential services, regeneration schemes or statutory functions. The key takeaway for councils is clear: robust governance, transparent evaluation records and disciplined process management remain the strongest defence against procurement challenges under the new regime.
The content of this page is a summary of the law in force at the date of publication and is not exhaustive, nor does it contain definitive advice. Specialist legal advice should be sought in relation to any queries that may arise.
Related expertise
Contact us today
Whatever your legal needs, our wide ranging expertise is here to support you and your business, so let’s start your legal journey today and get you in touch with the right lawyer to get you started.
Get in touch
For general enquiries, please complete this form and we will direct your message to the most appropriate person.